Chess24 Sopiko Scotch

Tradewise Gibraltar Chess Festival 2011 (4)

Short and N Kosintseva on 4/4. Ivanchuk's brilliant breakthrough

Deep Sengupta against Nigel Short. Photo ©

Deep Sengupta against Nigel Short. Photo © |

Nigel Short beat Deep Sengupta with the black pieces to 4/4 alongside Nadezhda Kosintseva. Vassily Ivanchuk made a nice rook sacrifice to win a game that otherwise would have been drawn. 79 year old Viktor Korchnoi remains undefeated.

Yesterday we were treated to some exciting chess, but the weather had deteriorated. I don’t believe there is a correlation here; good weather means less exciting chess and vice versa. No, I am not superstitious; basically the line-up of over 50 grandmasters and the selection of whom to offer hospitality by our main organisers, Brian Callaghan and Stuart Conquest, means that there is a feast every day.

Deep Sengupta against Nigel Short. Photo © Gibraltar Website. 2011

Truly, chess is a game of three halves (unlike football that never seems to manage more than two). Thus the all-female encounter between Victoria Cmilyte and Nadezhda Kosintseva went back and forth. When the music stopped, the elder of the two Kosintseva sisters emerged as the winner. This set her up for a fifth round encounter against Nigel Short, who beat the young Indian, Deep Sengupta, very convincingly.

Ivanchuk seemed to have a completely blocked position against the Hungarian GM Viktor Erdos. But he was permitted to play a rook sacrifice that had been on the cards for several moves.

Vassily Ivanchuk. Photo © Gibraltar Website. 2011

Round 4

Ivanchuk,Vassily (2764) - Erdos,Viktor (2593)

Viktor Erdos


Vassily Ivanchuk

Position after 39.Qe3


Both players had manoeuvred for many moves behind their respective barriers and a draw was the expected result, but now Black left open a sacrificial possibility. We don't know whether this was by design or accident.

39...Qa7 40.Rxd5!

There was a cry of "bravo" in the commentary room when Vassily played this enterprising move. It is probably the only move which could lead to a decisive result - though not necessarily a win for White.

40...exd5 41.e6+ Kh6 42.Rxd5 Rbd8 43.Rxd8 Rxd8 44.Bxf5

It gradually becomes clear that the sacrifice is sound, though Black might have put up a better defence to this point.

44...Qc7 45.g3 Rd1+ 46.Kf2 Qd8 47.Bc2

Now f5+ is a devastating threat, so Black has to give up the exchange.

47...Rd3 48.Bxd3 Qxd3 49.f5+! Qxe3+ 50.Kxe3 Ne7 51.Ke4 Bc6+ 52.Ke5 Nd5 53.b5! Nxc3 54.bxc6 Nb5 55.e7 Nc7 56.Kd6 Ne8+ 57.Kd7 Nf6+ 58.Ke6 Ne8 59.Kf7 Nc7 60.e8Q 1–0

A normal game of chess has one victor but this afternoon we had a game that started with two victors but ended with none (SR and JS worked together on this elaborate wordplay - some may think they could have been better occupied doing something else). Viktor Korchnoi played a great game against Viktor Bologan, but let it slip at the end so it petered out into a draw.


10 teams of four entered the team blitz on Thursday 27 January. The team of Berg, Jones, Williams, Rudd scored 17½ points to win £240. Second were Bologan, Onischuk, Gaponenko, Zhukova with 16½, netting £120.

Board 1: Bologan (Moldova), Soffer (Israel) 4/6. Board 2: Onischuk (USA) 5/6. Board 3: Williams (England) 5½/6. Board 4: Rudd (England) 5/6.


Challengers A (54 players) under 2250: Ivan Elishev (RUS) and Johan Henrikssen (SWE) scored 4½/5, each winning £1500.

Amateur A (30 players) under 1800: Vegard Stene (NOR) 5/5. Geoffrey Bishop (ENG), Alvaro Cardano Gonzalez (ESP), Armin Gholami (NOR) all scored 4/5.

Here’s a bizarre game from Challengers A which we have turned into a quiz for readers.

1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bb5 e5 4.0–0 d6 5.c3 a6 6.Bxc6+ bxc6 7.d4 exd4 8.cxd4 cxd4 9.Qxd4 Qf6 10.Qb6 d5 11.e5 Qe6 12.Nd4 Qd7 13.Nxc6 Ne7 14.Nd4 g5 15.Nc3 h5 16.Bxg5 Rg8 17.f4 Rg6 18.Qa5 Bb7 19.Rad1

what happened next was surprising…

Bruno Zanetti


Hristos Zygouris

Position after 19.Rad1

In this position Black played the illegal move


but neither player noticed that the black king had passed across an attacked square and the game continued:

20.Na4 Kb8 21.Rc1 Rc8 22.Nb6 Qd8 23.Bf6 Rxc1 24.Rxc1 Bh6 25.Qb4 Ka7 26.Bxe7 Qg8 27.Rc2 Bxf4 28.Bd6 Be3+ 29.Kh1 Rxd6 30.exd6 Qg4 31.Nc6+ Bxc6 32.Qxg4 hxg4 33.Rxc6 Bxb6 34.d7 1–0

Going back to the illegality: the penalty for making an illegal move is that your opponent receives two extra minutes and you must make a move with the piece you touched. However, in this example two pieces were touched in making the illegal move 19...0-0-0. Black has no legal move with the king but he has with the rook. Assuming the illegality had been identified at the time, could Black have been obliged to make a rook move instead? We’ll give you the answer in tomorrow’s bulletin.

The Challengers B and Amateur B start 30 January and, after a couple of rounds, we may know the precise number of players in the whole congress. That will not tell us the number who have been brought to Gibraltar; some people have come specially to see the action and other family members have also taken the opportunity to have a break.

Russian woman grandmaster Natalia Pogonina gave a master class in the commentary suite in the evening. As well as being a very talented player, Natalia runs a popular website (unsurprisingly called - where, amongst other things, she plays games against the World (similar to the famous game Garry Kasparov played against all-comers played some years ago). She showed us this entertaining game she won against the World and also her game with Tatiana Kosintseva from the Russian Women’s Super final at the end of 2010. The master class was recorded and can still be found on the tournament website.

Tournament Leaders: 1-2 Nigel Short (England), Nadezhda Kosintseva (Russia) 4/4, 3-6 Vasilios Kotronias (Greece), Vassily Ivanchuk (Ukraine), Richard Rapport (Hungary), Daniel Fridman (Germany) 3½.

Round 5 (of 10) starts at 3pm (GMT+1) on Saturday 29 January.

Gibraltar Masters Caleta ENG Mon 24th Jan 2011 - Thu 3rd Feb 2011
Leading Round 4 (of 10) Standings:
1Short Nigel DGMENG26584.03308
2Kosintseva NadezhdaIMRUS25524.03231
3Rapport RichardGMHUN25313.52914
4Ivanchuk VassilyGMUKR27643.52873
5Fridman DanielGMGER26553.52846
6Kotronias VasiliosGMGRE25993.52749
7Korchnoi ViktorGMSUI25443.02772
8Sengupta DeepGMIND25303.02748
9Sasikiran KrishnanGMIND26903.02737
10Felgaer RubenGMARG25853.02728
11Zhu ChenGMQAT24953.02723
12Cmilyte ViktorijaGMLTU25263.02722
13Adams MichaelGMENG27233.02709
14Buhmann RainerGMGER25723.02706
15Kulaots KaidoGMEST25773.02683
16Roiz MichaelGMISR26493.02678
17Harikrishna PentalaGMIND26673.02674
18Akobian VaruzhanGMUSA26183.02666
19Sandipan ChandaGMIND26413.02662
20Lafuente PabloGMARG25513.02635
21Gopal Geetha NarayananGMIND25973.02634
Krush IrinaIMUSA24833.02634
23Caruana FabianoGMITA27213.02633
24Georgiev KirilGMBUL26693.02616
Kacheishvili GiorgiGMGEO25853.02616
26Kosintseva TatianaGMRUS25703.02568
27Zatonskih AnnaIMUSA24933.02564
28Ikonnikov VyacheslavGMRUS25803.02555
29Kanep MeelisGMEST25313.02551
30Mikhalevski VictorGMISR25793.02524
31Vaarala EricSWE21523.02508
32Lemos DamianGMARG25533.02463
33Robson RayGMUSA25323.02446
34Sarkar JustinIMUSA24182.52722
35Vallejo Pons FranciscoGMESP26982.52620
36Dzagnidze NanaGMGEO25502.52616
37Weber TomFMLUX23102.52610
38Bellon Lopez Juan ManuelGMESP24042.52571
39Erdos ViktorGMHUN25932.52563
40Bologan ViktorGMMDA26932.52560
41Berg EmanuelGMSWE26272.52555
42Melia SalomeIMGEO24492.52539
43Onischuk AlexanderGMUSA26892.52533
44Nisipeanu Liviu-DieterGMROU26782.52529
45El Debs Felipe De CresceGMBRA24992.52484
46Valgmae ToomasEST21902.52475
47Oberhofer AndreGER22702.52470
48Edouard RomainGMFRA26342.52468
49Speelman Jon SGMENG25242.52463
50Soffer RamGMISR24892.52452
232 players

View the games on this Page

Download the PGN from this page


NIC Magazine 8 2017

Chess and Bridge Shop Pro-League

American Chess Magazine 4

ChessBase Ad 5 MyGames

Ginger GM - Chess Grandmaster Simon Williams

Contact Mark Crowther (TWIC) if you wish to advertise here.

The Week in Chess Magazine

Send a £30 donation via Paypal and contact me via email (Email Mark Crowther - I'll send you an address for a cbv file of my personal copy of every issue of the games in one database. Over 2 million games.

Read about 20 years of TWIC.

Read about issue 1200.

TWIC 1210 15th January 2018 - 2206 games

Read TWIC 1210

Download TWIC 1210 PGN

Download TWIC 1210 ChessBase